Peer Editing Definition Essay

Tags: Apa Style Essay OutlineEnglish Research PapersResearch Papers On Wireless CommunicationChristopher Columbus Research PaperEssays Drug Testing In Public SchoolsSecondly In EssaySteps To Writing A College Entrance EssayMy Turn Essay 2009Clep English Comp With EssayBell Hooks Essay

This can be done by modeling the process of reviewing a paper on an overhead transparency, creating guiding questions for review of an essay, discussing elements of an effective essay, and asking students to generate a list of things they feel that they should look for when reviewing each other's papers.

The goal is to "demystify" the process for students so that they can go beyond giving comments such as "This is great" or "Your paper stinks." Zemelman and Daniels (1988) offer specific suggestions to help encourage students to give helpful feedback to each other.

They suggest including items such as the following: identifying one good part of the writing and explaining what makes it good, asking at least one question about the writing, and identifying one place where they would like to hear more.

A third technique that they recommend is having peer readers mirror what is in the essay by simply telling the writer what they think the writing says as a way of seeing whether or not the writer communicated ideas effectively.

When students get their papers back they can easily see whether or not another reader was able to identify these elements in the essay.

Peer Conferencing When Time is Limited Strong's (2001) list of "shorthand symbols" can be helpful for giving quick feedback when time for peer conferencing is limited.Zemelman and Daniels (1988) caution that teachers may be frustrated if they simply put students into groups and tell them to read and respond to each other's writing without taking the time and energy to prepare them for the experience.They recommend training students over time to be participants in groups by structuring a series of activities that ultimately lead to reviewing each other's papers through peer conferencing.All too often, students flounder when it comes to peer editing essays.Not only is it confusing for students, but they often lack the direction and skills that they need to successfully peer edit a paper.He instructs students to read each other's papers and use the following four symbols to give feedback: means "I like this" * means "Say more here" ?means "This puzzled me" (check mark) means "Check for an error." Peer reviewers can use the symbols for individual words and sentences or put brackets around paragraphs or more extensive text with the symbol in the margin.In a point of view essay, for example, where students are stating an opinion, identifying reasons for that opinion, and supporting the reasons with elaboration, students could switch papers and use three different color highlighters to verify that the writer has stated an opinion (highlighting with blue), identified reasons (highlighting with pink), and supported those reasons with elaboration (highlighting with yellow).This technique can also be used to draw attention to a stylistic device such as use of vivid verbs, a language convention such as spelling errors, or an organizational issue such as use of transition.After that students move into guided peer review of each other's essays and finally end up becoming members of autonomous and flexible groups which can function during all stages of the process with limited teacher monitoring.Scarborough (2001) emphasizes that during this kind of community building it is particularly important for content area teachers to engage students in collaboration that is tied to the content of the class and not just "touchy-feely" activities in order to maximize their value.


Comments Peer Editing Definition Essay

  • Peer Editing - YouTube

    Jan 28, 2014. Helping each other by reading and making comments about your classmates work.-- Created using PowToon -- Free sign up at.…

  • Revision, Editing and Proofreading What's the Difference.

    Feb 14, 2011. Peer Writing Tutors & FYS Mentors. Catharine Wright explains the difference between revision, editing and proofreading. Revision Revision means “re-visioning” your paper. It is “big. It is important to check that your name is on your essay and it is desirable to number your pages or include a word count.…

  • Editing the Essay, Part One - Harvard Writing Center

    Anyone who has gone through the ecstasies and agonies of writing an essay knows the. You want every word in your sentence to add as much meaning and.…

  • Co-Writing, Peer Editing, and Publishing in the Cloud Web.

    Asking my students to co-write an essay, or simultaneously peer review each other's. Like collaborative writing, many faculty integrated peer editing into their. to the public web as a means to connect with broader communities of readers.…

  • Peer Editing Strategies That Actually Work For Student Writers

    Oct 7, 2014. When you ask your students to do peer review of their writing, do they stare at you with puzzled expressions? Here are five specific, hands-on.…

  • Ways to Foster Effective Peer Editing The TpT Blog

    All too often, students flounder when it comes to peer editing essays. statement in red, topic sentence in orange, examples in blue, and commentary in green.…

  • Peer Conferencing - NC Public Schools

    English/Language Arts Peer Conferencing. that the goal of peer conferencing is to help students edit their papers primarily for. all stages of writing as they select a topic, develop the essay, and revise a draft. means "This puzzled me".…

  • The Free Essay Editing Checklist That will Put You Top of the.

    This free editing checklist can help you to perfect your essay and take your grades up a. It's by no means definitive, but it's an ideal starting point if you find yourself wondering how the. How to Peer Edit an Essay Free Peer Editing Checklist.…

The Latest from ©